Originally posted on Variety:
It’s not just the protagonist who’s short of inspiration in “Not Another Happy Ending,” a trifling comedy about writer’s block that aims for a blend of Richard Curtis-style cheeriness and arch literary satire, and winds up mostly drawing a blank. An unusual Glaswegian setting and an appealing cast, led by rising star Karen Gillan as a ditzy novelist whose reluctant crush on her editor stalls the follow-up to her bestselling debut, combine to wring some charm from a lean premise that inevitably disproves its title. Commercially, however, a happy ending for this year’s Edinburgh closer may prove elusive even in Blighty.
Scottish director John McKay’s 2000 feature debut, “Crush,” a women-talking-dirty comedy starring Andie MacDowell, flopped in theaters but paved the way for a reasonably successful TV career. (His 2005 P.G. Wodehouse adaptation “Piccadilly Jim,” meanwhile, went straight to DVD.) The influence of the smallscreen is plainly evident in McKay’s third feature, from its sitcom-style scene structuring to its overreliance on pop-scored montages, which at least suggests it may play better in ancillary.
The initial appearance of Gillan’s perky Scottish writer Jane, dressed in full Annie Hall garb, suggests a quirkier comic tone than that struck shortly afterward by her goofy meet-cute with Tom (French actor Stanley Weber), a handsome, perma-stubbled independent publisher with a distractingly odd Franco-Scottish brogue. From there on, it’s standard romantic-comedy territory all the way.